- BnB Flow
- Posts
- 🏕️ Midwest Market Gems: Midweek STR Opportunities | January 01, 2025
🏕️ Midwest Market Gems: Midweek STR Opportunities | January 01, 2025
Prime STR Deals in Missouri, Minnesota, Michigan, Ohio, and Indiana
Special Edition: Best Short-term Rental Opportunities in the Midwest
January 1, 2025
Happy New Year, Investors!
Start the year off right with something special! Today, we’re unlocking all our deals to give you a taste of what BnB Pro members enjoy every day.
Discover standout Midwest properties like a cozy Indiana cabin with its own private pool or a beautifully updated home in Kansas City packed with neighborhood perks.
Take advantage of this one-day preview and start 2025 by exploring the kinds of opportunities that can elevate your STR game!
TODAY’S DEALS
Why it’s a top pick
This recently updated 4-bedroom home in Benson Place offers neighborhood amenities like swimming pools, walking trails, and a splash park, along with an attached garage. With an open floor plan and potential in the basement, it’s a solid short-term rental option with projected annual revenue of $64,000.
Property Highlights
List Price: $360,000
Layout: 4 Bedroom, 3 Bathroom
Size: 2,012 sq ft
Occupancy: 10-12
Key Features: Attached Garage, Recently Updated, Neighborhood Amenities
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $287
Occupancy Rate: 61%
Estimated Revenue: $64,000
Estimated Furnishing Cost (if unfurnished): $46,900
Estimated Gross Yield: 17.78%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Worlds of Fun, Arrowhead Stadium, Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas City Zoo
Desired Amenities: Fire Pit, WiFi
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Mar-Dec
Low Season: Jan
Comparable Rentals
Why it’s a top pick
This turnkey 5-bedroom, 4-bath lake villa on Middle Cullen Lake is a strong short-term rental opportunity. With waterfront access, community amenities like an indoor pool, sauna, and game room, and potential annual revenue of $115,600, it’s ideal for guests seeking a retreat with year-round activities and relaxation options.
Property Highlights
List Price: $549,000
Layout: 5 Bedroom, 4 Bathroom
Size: 2,944 sq ft
Occupancy: 12-14
Key Features: Turnkey Property, Waterfront, Community Amenities, Game Room
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $657
Occupancy Rate: 48%
Estimated Revenue: $115,600
Estimated Gross Yield: 21.06%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Nisswa Lake, Pillsbury State Forest, Northland Arboretum, Brainerd International Raceway, Paul Bunyan Trail
Desired Amenities: Waterfront, Hot Tub
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Jun-Aug
Low Season: Jan-Apr, Nov, Dec
Comparable Rentals
Join BnB Pro!
Why Upgrade to BnB Pro?
A Subscription That Pays for Itself: Access the full catalog of hand-picked, high-yield properties. Even a modest 1% boost in Gross Yield on a $500k Airbnb could mean an extra $5,000 in annual revenue—and with BnB Pro, you’ll often find deals with projected yields 5-20% higher, making it a smart investment.
Powerful Insights & Tools: Gain a deeper understanding of market trends, property performance, and guest preferences. Benchmark properties against similar listings, review successful past deals, and streamline your setup with curated item lists and message templates.
Join now and kickstart your investment journey.
Why it’s a top pick
This is a unicorn deal. This turnkey A-frame cabin on 5 wooded acres near Brown County State Park is an excellent short-term rental opportunity. Its rustic charm, spacious layout, and outdoor hot tub make it appealing to guests seeking a nature retreat. With potential annual revenue of $101,400, this property offers strong rental income potential.
Property Highlights
List Price: $395,000
Layout: 4 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom
Size: 2,660 sq ft
Occupancy: 10
Key Features: Turnkey Property, A-Frame, On 5 Acres
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $542
Occupancy Rate: 51%
Estimated Revenue: $101,400
Estimated Gross Yield: 25.67%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Brown County State Park, Downtown Nashville, IN, T.C. Steele State Historic Site, Yellowwood State Forest
Desired Amenities: Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Game Room,
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Apr, Jun-Nov
Low Season: Jan
Comparable Rentals
Why it’s a top pick
This is a unicorn deal. This updated lodge-style cabin on 2.46 acres offers strong short-term rental potential. Key features include an in-ground pool, detached garage with versatile space, and a relaxing wraparound deck. With its blend of modern updates and rustic charm, this property could generate an estimated annual revenue of $109,000.
Property Highlights
List Price: $349,900
Layout: 4 Bedroom, 4 Bathroom
Size: 1,892 sq ft
Occupancy: 10-12
Key Features: Updated, In-ground Pool, Detached Garage, On 2.46 Acres
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $514
Occupancy Rate: 58%
Estimated Revenue: $109,000
Estimated Furnishing Cost (if unfurnished): $48,100
Estimated Gross Yield: 31.15%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: McCormick's Creek State Park, Brown County State Park, Indiana University Bloomington, Hoosier National Forest
Desired Amenities: Hot tub, Fire Pit, Game Room
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Apr, Jun-Nov
Low Season: Jan
Comparable Rentals
Why it’s a top pick
This is a unicorn deal. This newly renovated ranch home, situated on a flat, usable lot, offers excellent short-term rental potential. With modern updates throughout and turnkey readiness, it could generate an estimated annual revenue of $44,400 while appealing to travelers seeking a fresh and functional space.
Property Highlights
List Price: $124,900
Layout: 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom
Size: 916 sq ft
Occupancy: 8-10
Key Features: Newly Renovated, Flat Usable Lot
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $193
Occupancy Rate: 63%
Estimated Revenue: $44,400
Estimated Furnishing Cost (if unfurnished): $40,750
Estimated Gross Yield: 35.55%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Detroit Institute of Arts, Belle Isle Park, Motown Museum, Detroit Zoo, Detroit Riverwalk
Desired Amenities: Hot Tub, Fire Pit
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: May-Oct
Low Season: Jan, Feb
Comparable Rentals
Why it’s a top pick
This is a unicorn deal. This turnkey Colonial home, blending historic charm with recent updates, is well-suited for short-term rental potential. Located in Highland Square, it offers proximity to the popular "Porchrokr" Festival and a spacious layout appealing to guests. With an estimated annual revenue of $58,000, it’s a strong option for investors.
Property Highlights
List Price: $155,000
Layout: 4 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom
Size: 2,568 sq ft
Occupancy: 10
Key Features: Turnkey Property, Recently Updated
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $260
Occupancy Rate: 61%
Estimated Revenue: $58,000
Estimated Gross Yield: 37.42%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Cuyahoga Valley National Park, Akron Zoo, Stan Hywet Hall & Gardens, Blossom Music Center, Akron Art Museum
Desired Amenities: Waterfront, Dedicated Workspace, Fire Pit
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Jun-Aug
Low Season: Jan
Comparable Rentals
Why it’s a top pick
This is a unicorn deal. This recently updated ranch home features a flat, usable lot, an attached garage, and a bright, open floor plan. Located in a desirable neighborhood, it’s a strong short-term rental candidate with projected annual revenue of $88,200, offering modern upgrades and functional appeal for guests.
Property Highlights
List Price: $250,000
Layout: 4 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom
Size: 1,566 sq ft
Occupancy: 10
Key Features: Recently Updated, Attached Garage, Flat Usable Lot
Analysis & Projections
Average Daily Rate (ADR): $416
Occupancy Rate: 58%
Estimated Revenue: $88,200
Estimated Furnishing Cost (if unfurnished): $45,700
Estimated Gross Yield: 35.28%
Market Factors
Reasons to visit: Historic Main Street St. Charles, Katy Trail State Park, The St. Louis Zoo, Gateway Arch National Park, Missouri Botanical Garden.
Desired Amenities: Hot Tub, Game Room, Theater
Average Length of Stay: 3 nights
Peak Season: Mar-Nov
Low Season: Jan, Feb
Comparable Rentals
THAT’S A WRAP
Today’s Midwest picks have landed! Did any of these potential investments spark your interest? Let us know how we're doing—we're always looking to improve BnB Flow.
Tomorrow, we're showcasing the finest deals from the Southwest!